Back to top
7 octobre 2026
Comités permanents
Comptes publics
Sommaire de la réunion: 

Salle des commissions
One Government Place
1700 rue Granville
Halifax, Nouvelle-Écosse

Témoins/Agenda:

May 2024 Report of the Auditor General – Health, Safety and Well-Being of Children Placed in Temporary Emergency Arrangements and Child and Youth Care Homes

Department of Opportunities and Social Development
- Craig Beaton – Deputy Minister

Sujet(s) à aborder: 

HANSARD

 

NOVA SCOTIA HOUSE OF ASSEMBLY

 

 

COMMITTEE

 

ON

 

PUBLIC ACCOUNTS

 

 

Wednesday, October 7, 2026

 

 

COMMITTEE ROOM

 

 

 

 

 

 

May 2024 Report of the Auditor General -
Health, Safety and Well-Being of Children Placed in Temporary Emergency Arrangements and Child and Youth Care Homes

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Printed and Published by Nova Scotia Hansard Reporting Services

 

 

Public Accounts Committee

Susan Leblanc (Chair)

Tom Taggart (Vice-Chair)

Hon. Trevor Boudreau

Tim Outhit

Rick Burns

Dianne Timmins

Lisa Lachance

Hon. Iain Rankin

Hon. Becky Druhan
 


 

 

 

 

 

In Attendance:

 

Kim Langille

Committee Clerk

 

Genevieve Harvey

Legislative Counsel

 

Morgan McWade
Acting Deputy Auditor General



Robert Jewer
Assistant Auditor General, Performance Audit Team


 

 

 

 

 

WITNESSES

 

Department of Opportunities and Social Development
 

Craig Beaton - Deputy Minister

Jill Barkhouse - Executive Director, Child & Family Wellbeing

Tracy Embrett - Executive Director, Service Delivery
 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

HALIFAX, WEDNESDAY, OCTOBER 7, 2026

 

STANDING COMMITTEE ON PUBLIC ACCOUNTS

 

9:00 A.M.

 

CHAIR

Susan Leblanc

 

VICE-CHAIR

Tom Taggart

 

 

THE CHAIR (Susan Leblanc): Order, please. I’m going to call the meeting to order. This is the Standing Committee on Public Accounts. Our mandate is that we are “established for the purpose of reviewing the public accounts, the annual report or other report of the Auditor General and any other financial matters respecting the public funds of the Province.”

 

My name is Susan Leblanc. I’m the Chair of the committee and the MLA for Dartmouth North. I use she/her pronouns. Before we begin, I’m going to remind everyone to please put your phones on silent, and should there be a need to leave the building, we will exit through the doors on Granville Street, and then gather at the Grand Parade.

 

Now I will ask the committee members to introduce yourselves. I’ll begin with the member on my left. Please tell us your name, your constituency, and your pronouns. Thank you.

 

[The committee members introduced themselves.]

 

 

THE CHAIR: We also have officials with us from the Office of the Auditor General, the Legislative Counsel Office, and the Legislative Committees Office here. On today’s agenda we have officials with us from the Department of Opportunities and Social Development regarding the May 2024 Report of the Auditor General - Health, Safety and Well-Being of Children Placed in Temporary Emergency Arrangements and Child and Youth Care Homes.

 

Welcome to our witnesses. I’ll ask you to introduce yourselves beginning with the witness on my left, and please let us know your pronouns as well.

 

[The witnesses introduced themselves.]

 

THE CHAIR: Great. Thank you very much and welcome. Just a reminder, you don’t need to touch your microphones. When I acknowledge you, Legislative Television will turn them on.

 

I will also say that when we get into the timed questions, we may have to cut you off at certain times. I allow the MLAs to flag me if they have heard enough of an answer and they want to move on, so I may call order. I apologize in advance for that.

 

Welcome, and I will ask Deputy Minister Beaton to make some opening remarks.

 

CRAIG BEATON: Good morning, Chair and members of the committee. As we’ve discussed earlier or introduced earlier, I’m joined today by my colleagues here: Jill Barkhouse, Executive Director of Child and Family Wellbeing, as well as Tracy Embrett, Executive Director for Service Delivery with Department of Opportunities and Social Development.

 

I want to start off by acknowledging the importance of this report and the significance of the issues it raises. Children and youth who come into the care of the minister are among the most vulnerable Nova Scotians. They deserve to be safe and supported and have caring adults and communities around them to help them thrive. As a department, we share that goal, and we take our responsibility to the children and youth very seriously.

 

The Auditor General’s 2024 report identified important areas where improvements were needed. We accepted all 20 of those recommendations and committed to acting on each and every one of them. Today, I am pleased to report that 17 of those recommendations have been implemented, and the remaining three are on track to be completed by the end of this calendar year. That work has strengthened oversight, accountability, monitoring, and quality assurance across the child and family well-being system.

 

We now have stronger processes to ensure that children and youth in temporary emergency arrangements have regular, required contact with their social worker and their plans of care are closely monitored. We’ve improved how we track and analyze serious occurrences, created a centralized system to investigate and monitor allegations involving children and youth in care, and put more consistent quality assurance practices in place across the system.

 

While implementing the Auditor General’s recommendations has been a priority, this work has also been informed by a broader transformation that’s been underway within Child and Family Wellbeing. Over the past few years, we have been working to strengthen services through a more child- and family-centered approach. Our Child and Family Wellbeing Practice Framework provides a consistent foundation for how we work with children, youth, families, caregivers, Indigenous communities, African Nova Scotian communities, services providers, and our partners. It’s based on the understanding that the lasting positive outcomes for children and youth not only depend on safety, but also on relationships, stability, belonging, and access to the right supports.

 

One important area of focus has been expanding and improving placement options for children and youth. Temporary emergency arrangements - or TEAs, as they’re referred to - are only intended to be used as a last resort and as a temporary measure when an appropriate foster home, kinship placement, or licensed care option isn’t immediately available or appropriate. The arrangements aren’t ideal and reducing them remains a priority. That’s why we’re focused on strengthening the system by expanding foster care options, increasing supports for caregivers, and developing specialized placements for children and youth with complex needs, and we are seeing progress.

 

As of August 2026, there were 19 children and youth in TEAs compared with the 138 that same time in 2022-23 when the report was dated back to. That’s a decrease of over 86 percent within TEAs and something that the department is very proud of. This progress is encouraging, but we know that any use of TEAs means we have work to do.

 

We also know that some children and youth have increasingly complex needs and require specialized services and supports. Building capacity to meet those needs safely and effectively continues to be a focus. We continue to strengthen oversight of our service providers, invest in the workforce capacity, improve data and reporting, and make sure concerns involving children and youth are identified, investigated, monitored, and addressed.

 

Our work is not finished. We’ve committed to continuous improvement and to learning from the experiences of children, youth, families, caregivers, staff, and our community partners. Our goal is straightforward: to make sure that children and youth are safe, supported, and connected to the services and relationships they need to reach their full potential.

 

We appreciate the Auditor General’s work and the committee’s interest in this

important issue, and we welcome your questions and opportunity to talk more about the progress we’ve made as part of the questions. Thank you.

 

THE CHAIR: Thank you very much, Deputy Minister Beaton. We will begin questions now and we will begin with MLA Lachance. Go ahead.

 

LISA LACHANCE: Thanks so much for being here. As you said, this is a really critical issue, and when we think of the role of government and the role of the state, this is one of those roles that is imperative to get it right. I know from our previous discussion here that we all share that commitment to kids thriving.

 

To put my cards on the table, I’ve worked with lots of young people who have been in care in Nova Scotia. I have a former youth in care friend who’s staying with us right now, and through work with Phoenix and other organizations, I’ve seen all of these issues play out in real time and real life. I’m quite passionate about it.

 

One thing that remains on my mind - what I look at are the outcomes. I look at the outcomes for former youth in care: less than half of former youth in care complete high school; less than 10 percent complete post-secondary; underemployment or unemployment. With the latest national data we have, 45 percent of unhoused youth had been in care at some point, and that’s certainly borne out anecdotally by the folks at Phoenix.

 

That’s sort of how I frame this. We’ve had this report. We’ve had attention to it. How can we improve these outcomes? I’ve worked with child and youth advocates across the country. I know the power of that office, particularly for children and youth in care in terms of investigating, researching, providing support - and that’s the one that we still don’t have here. I’ll come back to that.

 

Back to the recommendations from the report. You said that three recommendations still remain incomplete. I’m wondering what those recommendations are.

 

CRAIG BEATON: Thanks for the question. It is an important one because we know there are three that are still on the docket to be completed. As I mentioned, they will be done within this existing year. The first one relates to a case management system. We do reporting, but this is actually the IT function of the case management system that we’re looking at establishing, so making sure that any allegations of abuse and neglect are tracked appropriately and then monitored in terms of doing the analysis. That is scheduled to be up and running - I think November is the date that we should have that completed. We’re very close.

 

The second is around service level agreements with our child and youth caring facilities or programs. That work is well under way as well in terms of drafting those service level agreements. Those are basically ready for terms and conditions and signing. Those will also be done in this calendar year.

 

The third is the implementation, so the work around looking at background checks for staff who are working in child and youth caring programs, both the government and the non-government. Really where we’re at in that stage is about the implementation of those and getting that off the ground. It’s a periodic review, so even if you are staff who are there, there is a requirement after a certain number of years that you continue to have a criminal record check done. It’s just the implementation of that that we’re waiting for completion on.

 

I guess I would say we’re not checking them off the box to say they’re completed, but they’re well under way in terms of action.

 

LISA LACHANCE: With those three outstanding examples or the other 17 recommendations from 2024, how has that improved outcomes and experiences for youth in care?

 

CRAIG BEATON: I would echo your concern around outcomes. I would say it’s our number one North Star for the department when it comes to our Child and Family Wellbeing division. The thing that we’re measuring our progress on in terms of a mandate is looking at outcomes. That’s one of the things. What are the outcomes for the youth in care and how can we get those closer to the outcomes of those who are not in care? That is absolutely a driving factor behind the work that we do.

 

In terms of the Auditor General’s report, I think the fact that we’ve enacted all of the recommendations has certainly strengthened the system. It’s definitely strengthened the contact that we would have in terms of working with our youth in community and in those homes. There’s definitely more contact. Case management, obviously, is a big one in terms of reporting on occurrences so we can look at trends and analyses to better reflect what we are missing - where the are gaps associated.

 

That being said, I do think that outcomes - we tend to look at outcomes and think of that month-over-month progress. In some cases, that’s true, but the reality is outcomes and a big shift in terms of looking at changing the outcomes for youth is likely to take more than a couple years. If you would ask us this in two years’ time, I’m very hopeful that we’ll see more defined and better outcomes dating as far back of the data that we would have.

 

The progression around child and family well-being - you look at the numbers of youth in care as one outcome measure because we obviously want to reduce that number as much as we possibly can. We’ve seen about a 50 percent reduction in youth over the last 20 years coming into care, and it’s around 25 percent since 2017. I think there is progress, but it is measured in a longer period of time.

 

LISA LACHANCE: I understand the point about outcomes taking some time to develop. One of the things that could have been implemented a long time ago is a real and full child and youth advocate. This is something that the NDP has been focused on since before I was elected, but it’s also something that I did a lot of work on before being elected as well.

 

Since 2018, 640 youth in care have aged out without having the oversight and support that a youth advocate provides. I know there’s an Office for Children and Youth in the works, but that’s been talked about over whatever it is - six ministers, five years - and we still don’t have it. I’m wondering: When is that coming and is it going to be a real child and youth advocate, or what is going to be the role of the Office for Children and Youth?

 

CRAIG BEATON: Again, lots of interest in this one, I know. It’s been a question that we’ve gotten many times. What I can tell you is that the office does have a budget established for this year, so it is the full intention to have the office stood up within the remainder of this fiscal year. Right now, where we are in terms of development is finalizing regulations. Until those are finalized and signed off, that’s probably the extent of what I’d be able to share with you today. We are hopeful that those are moving pretty quickly, so we expect to see something soon.

 

LISA LACHANCE: I would just say that I feel like we’ve heard updates about this office: it’s almost there, it’s coming, or that the changes in legislation were to enable hiring a commissioner role. I think that the $300,000 that was allocated for this year doesn’t actually reflect what a full youth and child advocate role would be. I appreciate the update, but it’s another reason why it’s not in place, and children and youth have been waiting a long time. Like I said, I know that children and youth advocates have been so important in other provinces for being that extra level of advocacy and attention on youth in care, which, I know we all agree, are some of our most vulnerable Nova Scotians and one of our biggest responsibilities of government.

 

The CBC had a couple of important articles and stories last week around the experience of children and youth in care. They looked at 500 incidences where children or youth in the care of the Province ran away or were on the run or were unaccounted for. Most of that is from group homes. That’s a lot because there are only 150 young people living in group homes. What is the department going to do differently to ensure that youth living in group homes are not feeling so despondent that they are running away?

 

CRAIG BEATON: I think it’s important to outline some of the context around the critical incidents and the occurrences because it’s not all just about youth who may be missing for over a 24-hour period. There’s certainly some of that, and we take the care of those youth quite seriously. Obviously, it’s of the utmost importance. But those incidents are also highlighting that it could be a medical illness or an injury as well that’s reported in those numbers. I just want to make sure that the committee is aware of that - that there is context behind it. While I don’t know the breakdown, I think the fact that we have the reporting does strengthen our ability to look at that.

 

That was one of the items that was outlined by the Auditor General and something that I think we acted on right away, and again, the case management system will help strengthen that. I want to go back and say that the staff within the child and youth caring facilities are absolutely there with the best intentions, trying to support youth. Oftentimes, maybe the placement may not be the right place. We have increased contact between the social worker and the youth to make sure that there is contact that’s provided on heightened cases to make sure that the placement is supportive of the youth. Sometimes those placements break down and we have to look at alternate arrangements, so it really is the upfront care planning and re-looking at those care plans on a continuous basis that I think is going to help.

 

LISA LACHANCE: In terms of the types of serious incidents, can we do a follow-up with the committee and provide the breakdown of when those are medical incidents or when the youth is actually on the run? Because certainly, in my personal experience, I have seen what that looks like, and when it’s been repeated. Often, it is because that placement is just not appropriate - it is not working.

 

I think we still have very limited options in terms of where to place youth in care. I note the reduction in temporary emergency arrangements, which is positive, except that I’m wondering where kids are going. Last I asked, there are no Level 5 trained foster care families in this province. Previously, young people had to be sent out of province for the proper level of intensive services.

 

Maybe you could confirm, are there any Level 5 foster families? Are any young people being sent out of the province for treatment, in this fiscal year, in last fiscal year? Without temporary emergency arrangements, what are people doing? I wanted to say, too, of course, I believe the staff are always doing the best they can. It’s a strained system. There are not enough choices, there’s not enough range of services, and staff are 100 percent there with the best of intentions. But it’s hard to overcome a whole system, and by the time - particularly looking at group homes - young people have often had a history of trauma. They do need specialized services, and it is my contention that we don’t have those in Nova Scotia. I’ll leave the questions with you.

 

CRAIG BEATON: I think in terms of the specific questions that you’ve asked around Level 5, I’m going to probably have Jill jump in on that if that’s okay, but I want to follow up. I do agree that specialized services are obviously required and important. Back to the staffing component, as it relates to children in care, you’ve mentioned it. Our intention is never to take a child into care. We try to exhaust all options before that, and actually having them come in to a CYCP is absolutely our last option. A lot of these youth are faced with significant trauma, as you’ve mentioned. Unfortunately, as wards of the state, sometimes it is incumbent, through the legislation, for the minister to act as the conscientious parent and take that child into care and custody for the safety and well-being of the child. That is very traumatic.

 

When the child is coming in, there are often behaviours that come with that. The social workers and the staff do their best to mitigate that, but sometimes running and other issues are really hard to contend with because of the state in which the youth finds themselves. From my perspective, I think the staff does a very good job of trying to provide a stable environment, but sometimes it’s not always enough. I will have Jill maybe talk about the Level 5 specifically. And yes to the breakdown, we can get that, but we just don’t have it today.

 

THE CHAIR: Ms. Barkhouse.

 

JILL BARKHOUSE: Thanks for the questions specifically about the foster care system, and about where children go. I think it’s a great question. We always hope that children aren’t coming into care, and even when they do, we’re always hoping and planning for them to return home. Returning home could look like the home they came from, it could look like a return to kin, return to others in community, that’s always our goal. We do have some wonderful foster families who are highly skilled and have been providing care for children and youth for many years. Most of the foster families we currently have, what we would say provide a general level of care. Those would be families who are receiving children and youth...

 

THE CHAIR: Order, please. MLA Lachance.

 

LISA LACHANCE: I am so sorry, we have such limited time. I just really want to know, do we have the specialized level of foster families available in the province and are any children being sent out of province for care or for treatment?

 

JILL BARKHOUSE: Yes. The answer is yes. We do have specialized care within our foster care continuum. In addition to specialized foster care, we also have medical foster families who provide medical care. We have reduced the number of children who are leaving the province to receive treatment that they need. More often, when those needs arise, we are seeking treatment in province with our partners in community, within mental health, within education. We also have a secure care intervention or place, Wood Street Centre Campus in Truro, for the highest level of stability and care that is needed.

 

THE CHAIR: MLA Lachance, with about two and half minutes.

 

LISA LACHANCE: If you could follow up and indicate the number of specialized care foster families there are, and also year over year, of recent years, how many young people have been sent out of province for care. That would be appreciated.

 

I just wanted to get to another really important question around trafficking. We have an epidemic of gender-based violence in Nova Scotia. We have an epidemic of trafficking in Nova Scotia. I actually haven’t gone back and reviewed the data, but often it’s said we’re the worst province for human trafficking. It’s clear - and certainly I have understood this to be the experience of young people - that in fact, people prey on youth in care for human trafficking.

 

In terms of mitigating that, has the Province’s staff received training on sexual exploitation and trafficking? If so, can you share or perhaps follow up with the percentage of staff at group homes who have received this training?

 

THE CHAIR: Deputy Minister Beaton.

 

CRAIG BEATON: Yes, they do receive specialized training. We’d have to follow up with the percentage. I wouldn’t have that off the top of my head. You’re correct on the fact that people do unfortunately focus on youth caring facilities as a potential predatory environment for youth in care. We’re quite aware of that, which is why the training is there for all of staff, and awareness for the youth who are in those settings as well.

 

We do have a specialized home for youth who have been subjected to human trafficking or fleeing. We obviously don’t disclose the location of that home for a variety of reasons, but it’s something that we’re very focused on.

 

We have a full-time person within Jill’s team, a specialist who’s focused on this work and crosses over with not only the Advisory Council on the Status of Women but the Department of Justice, as well as Policing Services. It is absolutely front-of-mind and something that I think we’ve put a lot of attention to in the last year.

 

THE CHAIR: MLA Lachance with 20 seconds.

 

LISA LACHANCE: I think all of this - the going on the run and issues around trafficking - this is where a child and youth advocate would be so critical and really could lead to improved outcomes. We need to be listening to the experiences of young people to really understand what’s happening, especially as those challenges evolve over time, being able to match those with the services that young people are able to identify they want and need.

 

THE CHAIR: Order, please. I will move on to MLA Rankin.

 

HON. IAIN RANKIN: This is a super important topic, dealing with our most vulnerable folks in the province, especially our youth. There were some questions I was going to ask that were asked around the implementation of the recommendations. You talked about three recommendations that are outstanding that should be completed soon. The committee won’t have the benefit of talking about those recommendations and the implementation for quite some time, until there’s a follow-up, so I want to dive into the details of how those three are going to be implemented.

 

I did catch that you said there’s a decrease in terms of temporary emergency arrangements - a significant decrease in terms of how many - but equally important, I would say, is the length of stay. I was going to first ask about that average length of stay. The department told us that the AG found the average stay was over eight months. That’s significant. I just want to ask: Is there equal progress being made on the length of stay component and not just the number of kids who are in temporary or emergency arrangements?

 

THE CHAIR: Deputy Minister Beaton or Ms. Embrett.

 

CRAIG BEATON: I can start. Jill might have a little more information. Tracy was just showing me because I wasn’t sure if we had that stat. We do have one here, but I think it’s 9.6 months on average for the current youth that we would have in TEAs remaining.

 

IAIN RANKIN: Are there efforts to try to reduce that? Do you have a threshold of under six months? How’s that work coming along?

 

THE CHAIR: Ms. Barkhouse.

 

JILL BARKHOUSE: Yes, absolutely efforts to reduce that. Any number of months that children are away from family and in care that is not the most appropriate or there could be more suitable or appropriate options is too long. Lots of things are under way to try to reduce that time in temporary and emergency arrangements.

 

We’ve strengthened the social workers’ capacity for planning, for contact. We’ve increased oversight in alignment with the recommendations, monitoring and oversight for our temporary and emergency arrangements. We’re supporting social workers in their decision-making and planning around transitions for children and trying to support them in the least disruptive ways when another more suitable or appropriate option is found or when they can return home.

 

[9:30 a.m.]

 

IAIN RANKIN: Thank you - an important metric. Another one that I think should be tracked really carefully is the number of critical incidents. That was exposed with the report. Really when this came out, it was, I think, a damning report on the way that the government oversees these homes and that we’re not adequately overseeing the system with 1,900 critical incidents. Pretty serious, so I wonder if the department is tracking that. What are the goals to try to reduce that? Is there a number that we’re trying to reduce those critical incidents?

 

CRAIG BEATON: I can start, but I’m happy if Jill wants to chime in.

 

Yes. In terms of the tracking, I think we would agree that the Auditor General’s report obviously outlined a number of gaps that we had in terms of the monitoring and compliance of critical incidents. We acted on that right away. We do have monthly and quarterly reporting right now that we do produce. I think we’re able to take that information and look at what some of the trends are, and then put some analysis behind it to understand what some of the issues are and then how we need to evolve - care plans, placement options, etcetera - as part of ensuring that we are addressing some of those critical incidents.

 

It’s one of those cases where - again, I would go back. I think the majority of the staff working in these facilities are dealing with working to the best of their abilities, as we’ve outlined. The Auditor General’s report certainly outlined some failings in terms of documentation and reporting that we want to close the gaps on. I know that staff are absolutely doing that now - putting new policies and procedures in place. It’s one of those things when you know better, you do better. I think that there’s a real focus on it now to be able to address those concerns going forward.

 

Did you want to hear from Jill?

 

IAIN RANKIN: You can certainly keep going with this. I’m just looking at key metrics and the most serious metrics that we should be looking at.

 

The other one would be the percentage of required social worker visits. I think that really is a symptom of what the oversight issues are. It was in a CBC article last year that a social worker claimed that they had colleagues dealing with caseloads that exceed 50 cases, which exceeds the recommended number, which is around 16-20 cases. It could be a resource thing; it could be administrative and an effectiveness of using the resources.

 

What is the current average caseload for our social workers? Is this a metric that you agree with me - that the percentage of the visits from social workers is critically important and relates to reducing critical incidents?

 

CRAIG BEATON: A very important question. Part of the review did highlight this. One of the things that we’ve acted on is that in terms of oversight, there is required, when a child comes into care, a visit within seven days from the social worker. There are also three face-to-face visits that are required monthly and a weekly virtual visit as well that is needed as part of regular placement review. It’s done by the social worker, so that definitely enhanced in terms of the visitation and the visibility with the social worker.

 

You talked a bit about caseload rates. Caseloads are difficult at times because sometimes you have an open case and there’s documentation that’s required to close out the case. We know that social workers are best utilized when they’re out actually visiting with youth and families face to face, and sometimes that documentation lags. We put a big effort on in the last year to close out documentation to make sure that the true reflection of caseloads is actually around open caseloads and not necessarily ones that are just pending to be closed.

 

Currently, our caseloads across the province - this would vary based on offices because of vacancy rates within some so the caseloads may fluctuate. We’re at about 17.9 caseloads per social worker at this current moment.

 

IAIN RANKIN: I think all of this goes into the AG recommendation ensuring that you have a good case management system. I note that you said this will be ready next month - in November - so given that it’s going to be released very soon, I just want to ask some detailed questions about how that is going to be implemented - what that case management system looks like.

 

Will this provide a single real-time record of placement? Will it provide all of the incidents that are happening, the social worker visits, all the case plans, the health safety components? That’s my first question.

 

THE CHAIR: Ms. Barkhouse.

 

JILL BARKHOUSE: Yes, our case management system currently tracks those things and is the mechanism that social workers use to have accountability around their documentation and records - things like the child’s plan, which includes all of their needs, their strengths, their skills, their interests. It includes information about cultural identity, gender identity, other relationships, and important people. It is also currently including information about child safety assessments and investigations. In response to reports already that come when children and youth are living in child and youth caring programs, we can find that on our current case management system.

 

The piece that will be enhanced by the end of this year is the ability to specifically track the investigations and assessments that are just about the children and youth while they’re living in these child and youth caring programs.

 

IAIN RANKIN: I do see you have policies, but the AG report said that social workers weren’t contacting a child after their placement 40 percent of the time in their sample. Is that improving? What’s the current percentage of contact? What kind of enforcement has the department put in place to ensure that number improves?

 

You have a system, you have policies, but there is still the breakdown, and we’re interested as a committee if that’s improving with the new case management. Is there any kind of enhancement, as you refer to, to ensure that there’s a flag when this happens - when there’s an overdue required social worker visit or if a case review isn’t done? Is the system flagging this to make sure that it’ll happen?

 

JILL BARKHOUSE: Yes, the system is flagging that. There are some mechanisms built into the system already that will create activities or overdue reports and things for social workers to flag those important incidents. In addition, the temporary emergency arrangements and children’s placement in child and youth caring programs are regularly tracked and monitored. The oversight does include a review of the case management record for that child or youth. So there is some analysis done each time those are reviewed to make sure the appropriate documentation is there, and follow-up with social workers and others as needed when that contact requirement in the current procedures isn’t met.

 

IAIN RANKIN: I guess another important question around this is: Is there any kind of independence with this system to ensure that the system’s being used correctly? I think a lot of the answer is that there’s already a system that tracks, we kind of know all this, but what accountability is there to ensure there’s some level of independence around this system?

 

JILL BARKHOUSE: In terms of independence with the system and oversight, we do have specific roles within our child and family well-being program, with responsibility around regular reviews and contacts with staff throughout the system around procedures and policy implementation. We also have a system of specialists and program coordinators who have oversight and expertise around leadership and guidance for staff around the implementation and the practice that shows up with children and youth and families.

 

IAIN RANKIN: I’m focused on this because the AG said that basically the department has poor case management system. There are allegations of child abuse or neglect made by children living in these areas. Has the department incorporated tracking of allegations into your system?

 

JILL BARKHOUSE: Yes, we have incorporated tracking. Before the enhancement is available, that is done manually. Since the report was released in May 2024, there is a centralized provincial team that responds to referrals of abuse and neglect of children while they are living in child and youth caring programs. It is that centralized team that directly responds to those situations, reports and tracks those incidents.

 

IAIN RANKIN: There are two other recommendations that are really important, and I want to dive into the service level agreements, which is also, I think you said, is going to be ready this calendar year. We don’t have the benefit of looking at those today, but I think a lot of the questions should be known around: What are the mandatory staffing qualifications that you’re going to ensure that are in those agreements?

 

JILL BARKHOUSE: Also, in alignment with the report, procedures and our policy have been updated to reflect those requirements. Staff right now working in those child and youth caring programs will require some experience and educational requirements or qualifications around working with children and youth. Sometimes those are looking like undergraduate degrees or graduate degrees, also of diplomas in child and youth care, human services, those kinds of backgrounds.

 

We also have in place a number of checks: criminal record check, vulnerable sector checks, checks of the child abuse registry, which speaks somewhat to another one of the recommendations that we’re working to implement now in terms of the frequency and the ongoing nature of those checks.

 

IAIN RANKIN: Maybe I’ll jump to that one, because I am curious about that recommendation with background checks. There’s overlap. How many people in the system don’t have a criminal record check right now? Are there any, or can we guarantee today that we are ensuring that there are background checks? What is going to change relative to that recommendation in terms of frequency, ensuring that we have those background checks happening? What does that look like? Does it require full, clean - what is a background check requirement? There are a few questions in there.

 

JILL BARKHOUSE: I’ll do my best here. Currently, yes, staff working in both the government and non-government child and youth caring programs would have a criminal record check upon hire. We wouldn’t have staff working in those places who haven’t had that check when they were hired.

 

The implementation of this recommendation would see a couple of changes. It would see a requirement to have those checks completed at five-year intervals. Currently, it could be a one-time check. Those are valid, as we know, at that point in time. To address concern about risk to children ongoing and ongoing concerns that may come up or present, those checks will be done minimally every five years.

 

There’s also an attestation that will come into play with implementation of this recommendation, where new employees and current employees will confirm and attest to notify their employers if anything happens that could potentially cause concern or further harm.

 

IAIN RANKIN: Back to service level agreements. These are all related - these recommendations - but I think really important outstanding ones. I am interested in those service level agreements. What kinds of things can the department utilize to hold providers accountable, especially relative to critical incidents? Are there penalties worked in or other disciplinary actions or penalties that are embedded into these service agreements to ensure that we prevent these critical incidents from happening?

 

[9:45 a.m.]

 

THE CHAIR: Deputy Minister Beaton.

 

CRAIG BEATON: There’d be clauses within our agreements that would outline what the specific accountabilities and the reporting structures would look like for each of the organizations. Those would be built in. In terms of specifics, the agreements are fairly robust, so I wouldn’t have the details. I don’t even know if Jill would have the level of detail that you’d be looking for, but there definitely are pieces in terms of accountabilities contingent on funding, particularly around reporting requirements.

 

THE CHAIR: MLA Rankin with two minutes.

 

HON. IAIN RANKIN: I just think details are important with these recommendations. I’m not asking for a comprehensive review of each service level agreement, but maybe you could just speak to what the departments are expecting for minimal levels of standard in terms of supervision, in terms of ensuring that we have coverage, training, safety, and minimum health standards in these centres. What is the department going to do to ensure these standards are enforced and ensure that there are penalties if they’re not?

 

JILL BARKHOUSE: Currently, the service level agreements would outline a number of those things that you’ve talked about. High accountability with our partners - many of these partners have been trusted partners in caring for children and youth for a long time in this province. Things like staffing ratios, depending on the level of care, expectations around programming, culturally responsive care and service, pieces around attendance with education, working collaboratively with social workers and others in a child’s care planning team, supporting their admission to programs, supporting their transitions from programs when that happens, working to support reunification - all of those kinds of criteria are included in those conversations and agreements. Those accountabilities are clear in the agreements around funding and clauses around termination when expectations aren’t met.

 

THE CHAIR: Order, please. We’re going to move on to MLA Taggart.

 

TOM TAGGART: This is one of our more - I don’t know if the right word is difficult challenges or subjects to come before Public Accounts Committee. It’s guaranteed that there’s nobody around this table who doesn’t care deeply about the situation that is there. I think I want to start by recognizing and thanking not only the staff from leadership to on the ground in your department for the work they do in very difficult situations. I think just to comment, we talked about a child and youth advocate. I would think that every employee of your department is a child and youth advocate.

 

I want to recognize them and thank them for their work, as well as Ms. Barkhouse, you mentioned your trusted partners. I happen to have - I don’t know if they still are, because they’re aging out like I am - family whose children grew up with ours. They brought children in and took care of them, I think some troubled youth amongst them. They were great, and I’m sure others are great; a very valuable piece of the system. I just want to say that up front. We’ll critique and there are always ways that somebody can suggest that we do better, and there’s no doubt we can, but I want to make sure that I recognize the value of those people.

 

Having said that, over time, things improve. There should be continuous improvement. I’m sure there is, as things evolve. We started out at 2024 with all these recommendations, and most of them are finished. It’s just a way of showing it’s evolving. This well-being practice framework, tell us how it is changing the way that you folks provide that much-needed service right now? Can anybody speak to that? We’re kind of all headed in the same direction here, but I’d just kind of like a little more detail on that if I could.

 

THE CHAIR: Deputy Minister Beaton.

 

CRAIG BEATON: I think maybe I’ll start and turn it over to Jill. think you’ve mentioned we’re fortunate to have some real experts and leaders in this area, not only here from Nova Scotia but I think nationally. Jill herself has over 30 years of experience in this area working in many provinces, Indigenous communities. It brings a whole wealth of experience to what the involvement and how we would lead a practice framework of what that actually looks like.

 

The practice framework was well under way when I came a little over two years ago, and it’s something that the department has spent a significant amount of focus on. You can imagine that it’s a significant change undertaking as well, not only just with staff but also with community. For years, I would say bringing a child into care is a traumatic experience for everybody, not only for the youth but also for the families. Trust is very difficult when you’re talking about how that trust is seen between the family or the parent. Really, what we’re trying to establish is the ability to make sure that reunification is right out at the outset.

 

The department’s done a number of interesting things. One that I think is really important to highlight is we have specialized funding which essentially means that when a child does come into care, what we’ve made recognition of is the fact that we want the family to be able to reunify as quickly as possible.

 

Many people would be familiar with the Canada child benefit. That goes to families when they have children at home. When a child comes into care, that payment ceases at a federal level, but Nova Scotia, we’ve actually implemented a payment that continues that to the family even though the child is not there so that they can actually keep up the necessary needs within their household to be able to allow them to come back into the home. We’re the only province that does that, and I think that is paying dividends. I know in the last year there were over 211 families that have been impacted as a result of that, and that’s really a first signal to us in terms of gaining that trust with the family to say we absolutely want to reunify.

 

You mentioned trusted partners. We have some of the best organizations around the province that are doing just that. Whether it’s Parenting Journey programs or A Place to Belong programs targeted toward youth, Strengthening Fathers, we have a whole host of those, and Jill can talk quite specifically about those. All of those are geared toward prevention and around trying to ensure that we don’t actually have to take children into care.

 

Back to the framework, it really does give us a guideline in terms of how we implement that. How do you actually move about a process of ensuring that you’re focusing on not bringing the child into care, and if you are, how quickly can you move them back out into family reunification? Happy to let Jill talk a little bit more about some of the framework stuff or we can move onto other questions.

 

TOM TAGGART: I don’t want to take a lot of time, but I would love to hear that.

 

CRAIG BEATON: Sure.

 

THE CHAIR: Ms. Barkhouse.

 

JILL BARKHOUSE: I love to talk about the practice framework. We’re really proud of that piece of work that my colleague actually started and led with the Child and Family Wellbeing division. The practice framework is really the foundational piece for all of us in delivery of Child and Family Wellbeing services but also, in the development of programs and designing programs, drafting policies. It is the piece that guides how we show up, how we approached our work with children, youth, and families. It positions our services by government and our interventions which sometimes can feel intrusive. It positions those services as part of a community of caregiving.

 

Certainly, we have a role to play and a very specific role in terms of responses to child safety where harm has happened. That can look a number of ways in terms of how we support families and how we help them to keep children safe. Our goal is really to have children at home and in communities and to be part of that broader community that does wrap around children and families to do that.

 

Our practice framework has been culturally informed and continues to be. We continue to rely on teachings from the African Nova Scotian communities. Our Mi’kmaw partners continue to guide us in the approaches around cultural humility and consistency in caring.

 

We do provide some supporting guidance around how social workers are enhancing their practice, and we’ve heard lots of good stories about how children are supported at home. We’ve seen outcomes in terms of the implementation of the practice framework resulting in reduced numbers of children coming into care. We’ve been able to enhance community programs that see prevention supports to families so that children can stay in their communities and families can have the support they need when they need it.

 

THE CHAIR: MLA Outhit, please.

 

TIM OUTHIT: Thank you for being here today, but also, as my colleague said earlier, thank you and great respect for the folks who work with you in a very complex, important, and difficult capacity. It certainly is appreciated.

 

We touched a little bit on caseloads in a question from a colleague, but I’d like to understand a little bit more. We hear about the incredible pressures and challenges that social workers face. While the caseload has reduced, which is a good thing, I’m wanting to understand a little bit more about what you’re trying to do to help the folks on your team with their own social, mental, and emotional well-being in a very demanding career.

 

THE CHAIR: Ms. Embrett.

 

TRACY EMBRETT: We are very pleased with the reduction in caseloads. It is one of probably the most challenging positions in all of government to support families on their most challenging day with the children they love and care for when they need support and assistance to do so. The complexity of cases, the geography of Nova Scotia - all of those are additional layers of challenge sometimes for caseworkers. The practice framework has completely supported the reduction in cases as well, because it does require us to look at prevention and early intervention prior to bringing a child into care.

 

The procedures manual puts decisions very close to the social worker and their supervisor whom they consult with on an ongoing basis. We did go from a policy manual that was, I think, 1,600 pages down to about 225 pages of policy with procedure being a living document that we continually get feedback on from social workers, from service providers, community providers, and families as well on if we did something right or if there’s another way to do that.

 

We are also continually looking at how we can support social workers in the challenging work. We have changed how we do our hiring. We use regional pools or provincial pools to do hiring, so we are very pleased as well that our vacancy rates for social workers are right now at about 7 percent. I’m going by memory, but they were definitely higher when we were here last time. I think they may have been as high as 15 percent, but we can confirm that. We are also hiring retired social workers if they’d like to come back and do a piece or part of the job that they enjoyed the most. For some social workers who have retired, that may be going out and meeting with families; for others, it may be closing files or doing work within the office.

 

Part of our recruitment and retention includes consideration for relocation expenses if a social worker is moving from another province, as an example. We increased the classification for child protection social workers, which recognizes the complexity of their jobs. I’m very pleased to say, the last time we were here, I was in Child and Family Wellbeing, and now I’m back in service delivery, part of the hiring and support of social workers. We are seeing people who had previously left Child and Family Wellbeing returning. When I see a name or a resumé come across my screen with a note of people wanting to return back to this work because of the changes we made, that’s a huge validation that we’re on the right path.

 

We remain committed to addressing administrative burdens and monitoring caseloads. Any tech that we can use to support what we would identify as administrative duty, we are all in. We also have a peer support program that we are piloting in our department in two offices in partnership with the Office of Workplace Mental Health. They’ve had very successful launches in other departments like Corrections and Natural Resources. We’ve had some reach outs there.

 

There is also a peer support group that has started up that is for new Canadians, as well, who are experiencing different adjustment challenges, maybe when they’re coming here. A lot of supports - we have an enhanced critical response program in the Central Region that we’re piloting, and we’re continuing to engage social workers and supervisors. We have about 420 social workers who work in Child and Family Wellbeing in the province, and we’re engaging them on a regular basis on practice and policy, as well as consultation and guidance and what they would like to see.

 

TIM OUTHIT: That’s a very encouraging and thorough answer. I like to hear things like 1,600-page manuals dropping down to 200; that wasn’t just font changing and bigger pages, I hope. That’s good. In the deputy minister’s comments, something tweaked my interest. He explained a little bit about the TEAs and what that involves, and something around the reduction of almost 80 percent of folks being in that situation. You’ve obviously looked at some different ways of doing placements and improved how you do things, but I’m really interested in tying back in to what allowed you to see that significant reduction, what you’ve learned that allowed you to do that. I’m not sure who’s best to answer that. Maybe Jill? She seems excited.

 

THE CHAIR: Ms. Barkhouse.

 

JILL BARKHOUSE: It is exciting work. We have seen a significant reduction in temporary emergency arrangements for children and youth who find themselves there. That is the result of some really focused work over the last number of years. We’ve had a dedicated core team of staff and leadership who have been diligent about understanding each child and youth circumstance and ways to help them make decisions about who else and where else they might be and live and thrive. Those reductions have been made through those efforts especially.

 

I would also say, in terms of reducing the number of TEAs, we’ve really made a lot of progress in terms of our foster care redesign, a lot of enhancements in our foster care system to support foster families. We have ongoing activities around recruitment of foster families. We’ve implemented a new design of the foster care system that has 54 what are called constellations, but really, by their nature, are communities of care. They’re communities of foster families who meet regularly, who host events together, who support each other, and who act as a resource for each other when child care is needed, when there are emergencies, so children can feel more naturally supported with families in communities of care. Those enhancements have really strengthened our foster care system and have helped foster caregivers feel supported in the care that they give.

 

We’re also focused on reunification, always. When children and youth are living in temporary emergency arrangements, social workers are actively connecting with them, talking with them, hearing their voice, hearing about their wishes, and in many cases working with their families.

 

Reunification is very often the goal. To do that, we’ve got a number of supports in place that can support children returning to families and returning to communities. If not their home, we have a program that is our alternative family care program, that has more than 350 children living with alternative family caregivers in their communities. That has, in and of itself, prevented them from coming into care and perhaps needing to be in a temporary emergency arrangement.

 

We’ve also been working with our child and youth caring programs and have worked in terms of their programs and care of children. We’ve developed specialized resources in those programs to meet specific needs of youth, things like sexual exploitation and human trafficking, for example.

 

We’ve also been working around children and youth who have different abilities and whose needs might be different and not completely met by a child and family well-being system, but who may need health supports or mental health supports or educational transition supports. We’re working really hard to build those networks for children to be successful regardless of where they live.

 

THE CHAIR: MLA Outhit with 30 seconds.

 

TIM OUTHIT: I will just say thank you very much. Your excitement and your passion are a good thing. I want to mention that. I really appreciate seeing that in your response as well as your knowledge, so thank you.

 

THE CHAIR: That was the conclusive first round. Just before we continue to the second, I have a request as the Chair. I don’t usually do this, but just listening to the questions and the answers, I’m hoping that maybe the committee could get confirmation by letter or email when those three remaining recommendations are over the finish line, so that we can get them into our correspondence and just know that we can feel satisfied that those are being done, so that we’re not waiting for the next Auditor General report. Is that possible? I’ll get Kim to follow up with you on that request.

 

Okay. We’ll return to MLA Lachance. We have about 12 minutes, so I’ve got you until 10:20 a.m.

 

LISA LACHANCE: From the discussion today, in terms of accountability – which, obviously, was a lot of what’s been addressed and being built out of the Auditor General’s report, the experience of young people in care and outcomes - I remain a staunch advocate for an advocate, in fact. I think we agree these are the most vulnerable young people who, by virtue of being young people as well as young people in care, lack a lot of agency and a lot of power. What I’ve seen across the country is that an advocate’s office has been such an important part of ensuring that their voices and their experiences inform government policy. At this point, is there any way that you hear from youth in care or former youth in care?

 

THE CHAIR: Deputy Minister Beaton.

 

CRAIG BEATON: The answer is yes. We have quite an extensive involvement, not only with youth in care but maybe former youth in care who have their mechanisms, and report through the Office of the Ombudsman. We have a number of files that we engage with the Office of the Ombudsman on, and they do their appropriate investigations. I think that through the contact they have with social workers as well, it’s another avenue for youth who are currently in care to be able to make sure that their voice is heard. The very nature of social work is that they’re advocates for the people they are looking after. We do hear that quite extensively from the teams, through the appropriate channels.

 

LISA LACHANCE: Just to stay on the office of an advocate, I think what’s different is that it allows an ongoing and accountable way of seeking input and experiences, which is really important. One-off chances are important as well, but to really move that type of system, engagement needs to be consistent and have its own set of accountabilities.

 

We’ve seen six ministers come and go in five years in this department. I can’t quite imagine, having been a public servant, how destabilizing that is for a department. I know when ministers change it’s challenging and complicated when it happens. Each one of those six ministers has said, “Okay, this is the year, under my watch, we’re going to have a child and youth advocate in Nova Scotia.” So far, that has not come to pass.

 

I am concerned that we’re now sitting in October of this year, and the regulations are still being developed. We don’t have someone appointed as the leader of that organization. Only $300,000 have been allocated for this year.

 

Is it realistic that that $300,000 is even going to be spent on establishing a true child and youth advocate? I’m skeptical of the likelihood of implementation success in this fiscal year, and I’m wondering if you have any comment on that.

 

CRAIG BEATON: I think the establishment of the $300,000 was really in reflection to the likelihood or the timeline of us being able to implement the office within the fiscal year. So $300,000 would be a pro-ration of what would be required for the office on an annual basis. That’s typically how the forecasting would work. We feel pretty confident that we will see some use of that funding over the course of the next number of months, with the establishment and once those regulations pass. I feel confident that we’re in a place where we will see some movement around the office.

 

LISA LACHANCE: Just to quantify some movement around the office, when do you expect the regulations to be presented for approval?

 

CRAIG BEATON: I wouldn’t be able to speak in terms of the Treasury Board agendas, but those obviously would have to be put forward on an agenda, but we expect it in the coming weeks, months. I know that’s vague, but that’s about all I can tell you.

 

LISA LACHANCE: I guess I would just say that this is something that children and youth in care in other provinces have had access to for decades at this point. The fact that we’re dragging our way through the mandate of six ministers and another fiscal year - I know lots of things have to come together to make this happen, but I’m not sure the vague answers we’re getting here today are good enough. I don’t think they’re good enough for the promises that have been made to all Nova Scotians. This was a 2021 election promise, and I don’t think it’s good enough for youth in care.

 

The other thing that’s so important - and I know you know this, I know you share this - when we miss years, we’re missing parts of childhood development and youth development. It’s a ticking clock. Our ability to make impactful interventions in the development of a young person is time limited. I leave it at that. From where I sit, there are lots of provinces that have this model, there’s lots to learn from, and it has taken too long for this province to get going on this issue.

 

I have a couple of other questions. This will be a bit of a rapid round. Again, we’re talking about outcomes. When young people age out of being a youth in care and they are homeless - and we have established that there’s a great percentage of young people who are homeless across the country and in Halifax who are former youth in care - do they receive the essentials rate or do they only receive the $410? What do former youth in care who are homeless receive in terms of income assistance?

 

THE CHAIR: Ms. Embrett.

 

TRACY EMBRETT: I will talk about two options for youth who are transitioning to adulthood. We do have post-care and custody agreements for youth who are in care and are transitioning to post-secondary training or education. That will continue to be funded, provided the social worker will continue to work with that youth and will also pay living expenses, or support living expenses of the individual.

 

Also, we have the Path program that was rolled out in January 2025 - I believe that was the beginning of Path. The Path program is a funding option available to all youth who transition from care or a youth services agreement at the age of majority, so either 19 or 21.

 

THE CHAIR: Order, please. MLA Lachance.

 

LISA LACHANCE: Just because of time - I do have some questions about the Path program so I’m just going to launch those at the same time. My question is: If you’re a former youth in care, either from the child welfare system here in Nova Scotia or another province, and up to the age of 26, which is when Path goes until, if you are homeless, do you receive the full income assistance amount or only the essentials amount? What is the amount? Is there any special consideration for former youth in care who are homeless in this province?

 

In terms of the Path program, how many young people are currently enrolled, and also pathways to that program. A lot of times, what I have observed, is that young people come out of care, they age out at the age of majority, and they need some time to reconcile with dealing with the system again. My question is: Can people come back? You age out at 19, but if you come back at 22 and say, “I’m ready, I really want this support.” So: numbers on what do homeless former youth in care receive in terms of income assistance, how many youth are in the Path program, and how can they access that?

 

THE CHAIR: Ms. Embrett with about two and half minutes.

 

TRACY EMBRETT: I can confirm there are a lot of questions there, some of the information we’ll have to gather, but there are supports beyond financial supports for youth being supported by the Path program. Family Service Nova Scotia has housing support workers. There is job support - it would depend on the need of the individual. Also, any funding provided by Path is not reportable as income for Service Canada nor for Income Assistance. I can’t confirm the exact rates that they would receive, it would depend on their living circumstances, but the Path funding that is received is not factored into their Income Assistance application.

 

LISA LACHANCE: Perhaps we could follow up on that - the numbers of young people in Path since it was initiated, the income assistance level that someone would receive. I know we’ve got a whole list that Kim is collecting of follow-up questions.

 

In terms of staffing and the importance of supporting staff in this really critical work - whether that’s in the department or outside the department - earlier this year, Arden Professional Client Care, which is a service provider for the Province for vulnerable children and disabled adults, lost of a lot of their trained staff, their experienced staff, because a CRA audit found they weren’t reporting their employment status properly. The end result is that there is a great deal of destabilization of the services, and workers were facing tax bills of tens of thousands of dollars.

 

Will the new service level agreements prevent this type of situation from happening? Will the new service level agreements look at the status of organizations and ensure they’re treating their employees correctly?

 

THE CHAIR: Deputy Minister Beaton.

 

CRAIG BEATON: I think in respect of the organization that you’re referring to, the service level agreements won’t get into the details of an employer-employee relationship. That’s really for them, as a private company. The expectation is for them to live up to the employment standards. Our service level agreements, as Jill has mentioned, most of which - Arden Professional Client Care would provide support to TEAs, and our child and youth caring programs are mostly done through non-profit organizations. We have great organizations that represent them - HomeBridge Youth Society, Chisholm Services for Children, Akoma Family Centre, the list goes on in terms of folks who would operate, but those service level agreements wouldn’t necessarily define the employer-employee relationship. It would talk about the outcomes expected in terms of delivery of services to youth in those settings.

 

THE CHAIR: Thank you. We’ll move on to MLA Druhan, please.

 

HON. BECKY DRUHAN: I want to thank all of you for being here today. I have a few questions that cover some of the ground that has already been covered but it really digs a little deeper into each of those items. The first area I want to start on is in relation to the child and youth advocate. We’ve had a few questions on that already.

 

Just so that we know what we’re talking about, an office of the child and youth advocate typically would be an independent office. In some instances, it’s actually an independent office of the House of Assembly. Its job is ensuring that children’s rights are protected and respected. As an independent office or role, they often will do investigations, review of complaints, they will do individual advocacy but also systems advocacy. I think it’s important to say that because I’m hearing a difference in concept - I hope that I’m hearing a difference in concept - let me just rephrase the question.

 

I appreciated when Deputy Minister Beaton mentioned that the amount of $300,000 was a pro-ration, anticipated to be something that will start at the end of the year which in my mind means that the amount invested next year should be significantly more which it would need to be if an office is going to fulfill the kinds of functions that these types of offices do across the province. I was concerned to hear MLA Taggart reference that he considers every staff in your department to be a child and youth advocate.

 

I’m just going to be clear: I understand and deeply appreciate that the staff in your office and then others on the team and contractors are deeply committed to the children and youth they serve and act as advocates in many cases for those children and for those families; but it is a very different thing to be a staff who has a very specific set of responsibilities, a caseworker, for example, who is responsible to those individuals and those actions. It is a very different thing from an office, an independent office, that has a systemic and independent role. That contrast really had me a little concerned, so I want to follow up on that question and to truly understand. Is the scope that is being contemplated of this office truly a systemic and independent scope that looks at advocating for the well-being of children across Nova Scotia, or is it, as MLA Taggart has suggested, a much more limited function?

 

THE CHAIR: Deputy Minister Beaton.

 

CRAIG BEATON: In terms of the scope, I think I mentioned earlier in my comments that regulations are currently being developed. It would be inappropriate for me to get out in front of the approvals because obviously there is an approval process to go forward in terms of those regulations to be approved by government. The details of those regulations are being currently worked on, and those will come out once those regulations are approved in terms of what the office will look like. I think that’s about the amount that I can say about the specific details in terms of the structure of the office right now.

 

I think I did also mention - and I think it is important - there are a number of avenues currently right now for youth in care and youth aging out of care to be able to reach in to make sure that their concerns are heard. I talked about the Nova Scotia Office of the Ombudsman. There is also another committee that Tracy reminded me of - the Let’s Care Collective - that youth aging out of care have the opportunity to have their voice heard through the department in terms of issues that they’ve experienced or face.

 

I will say that the actual role of a social worker is to advocate on behalf of their clients. We do hear from social workers quite frequently around concerns in community in terms of advocating for the youth in their care. As a lead-in, I don’t want to leave people with the impression that because the office hasn’t been stood up that there aren’t things in the background working to support youth in care, and certainly the department takes all of those instances very seriously.

 

BECKY DRUHAN: I want to thank you, deputy minister. I do want to acknowledge that I know that the staff take their advocacy role very seriously. We have talked at times as well about the other types of organizations and offices that are available to advocate, such as the Ombudsman and the Let’s Care Collective. What I would say is that I appreciate that this is the provincial government’s promise. It is incumbent on the elected officials to move it forward and provide the direction to the department and the funding for the department to make that move forward. I just want to be clear.

 

I appreciate that the department is acting on the resources and the direction that is available to them. To the extent that there remains a question that I have, and I think my colleagues have, about this government’s commitment to moving ahead with the actual office. That question, I recognize, is not for this table; it’s to be directed to those elected officials within government.

 

I do appreciate you sharing those details about what is currently available in the system. It’s important that people are aware of that, and that youth and families are aware of that.

 

I want to move now to a couple of things that I’m going to thread together, because I’m curious if they relate to one another. My colleague asked about length of stay in emergency placements. If I remember correctly, when the report was issued, it was over eight months at that time. It appears that has actually extended now. We’re still looking at significant lengths of stay for youth in emergency care placements. I am curious if you can share with us the relationship there is between moving youth out of those emergency placements and into, for example, foster homes and foster families.

 

The reason I ask about that is that we know core funding was eliminated for the Federation of Foster Families. I’ve certainly, in my community, heard about the concerns directly from foster families who were worried about the loss of services that the federation provided, particularly around being a centralized provincial voice and the advocacy and allegation support that the federation provides to those families.

 

I wonder if - recognizing that is a budgetary decision by the minister and Cabinet, not by department - that decision and the impact it may have on foster families, and I will suggest the potentially chilling impact it may have on foster families who are in the system now or new families. That’s the effect that I had heard from people in my area who are foster families and are worried, and the availability of foster families. How does that impact on that length of stay?

 

THE CHAIR (Tom Taggart): Deputy Minister Beaton.

 

CRAIG BEATON: I think those two things are probably fairly different in terms of lengths of stay with the TEAs versus the impact of foster families and feeling support from the Foster Federation and the lack of potential support going forward in the future. I’ll do my best to address both of those. Obviously, the length of stay has increased a little bit from eight months, I think, to 9.6, roughly where we’re at right now.

 

That being said, I think the progress of having an 86 percent decrease in the number of TEAs is really, I think, a huge metric to move. Therefore, the remaining folks and youth who are left in TEAs or find themselves in TEAs are typically probably very complex in terms of the needs and the specialized services that are reported. You’re seeing a little increase as a result of that. That would be the main answer on that particular portion.

 

I can certainly go into the Foster Federation if you wish, or if you had other questions. Obviously, the Federation of Foster Families Nova Scotia, you’re correct, a budgetary decision, but I do think that the strength within the foster family model and the Mockingbird Family model, which you may have heard of, is something that we’ve pulled from internationally, but also one of the first in Canada to implement. There’s been significant interest from our other colleagues because of the impact that it’s had for families within foster - I’m getting the...

 

[10:30 a.m.]

 

THE CHAIR (Susan Leblanc): Order, please. We’re getting the flow of this. It’s just a look now. MLA Druhan.

 

HON. BECKY DRUHAN: I appreciate the role of the communities of care and the Mockingbird Family model, but they are different things. As we were talking about the child and youth advocate, there are different ways to advocate and support. A community of care is not the same as having an independent organization that advocates for you and provides supports.

 

I’ll move on now, recognizing that I have very little time. I did want to ask about the report of serious incidents at group homes, particularly around many children running away and the frequency of that. A number of questions were asked about that already by my colleague, but there was one particular area that I wanted to focus on. It was reported that former group home residents interviewed said that being moved around from group home to group home severed the social connections they may have made and was a contributing factor in running away.

 

I’m curious about the placement information collection tool that the Auditor General spoke about. My understanding is that tool is necessary to determine the best needs for a child or youth to avoid too many movements, which would presumably help with this issue. I’m wondering what the department has determined is the necessary frequency of administering that tool. Has the tool been improved upon to hopefully address these factors and reduce the likelihood that youth will be running away?

 

THE CHAIR: Ms. Barkhouse with 30 seconds.

 

JILL BARKHOUSE: Yes, the tool has been enhanced. It includes a number of factors, including strengths and highlighting strengths and needs. It is done with frequency whenever a social worker is looking for a place for a child in care to live that is outside of their home and community. Upon coming into care and any time a child needs to move, it’s updated and reviewed.

 

THE CHAIR: I’ll move on to MLA Timmins, please.

 

DIANNE TIMMINS: Thank you for the support that the department has been providing for this critical service for foster care and child and youth. I know you’ve talked about the support of the transition for youth. I know with the numbers decreasing, I’m assuming those numbers are because youth are aging out and are of age and moving on to another transition in their life. The strengthening support for youth transition to adulthood, can you explain some of the process that the department goes through to provide those services?

 

THE CHAIR: Ms. Barkhouse.

 

JILL BARKHOUSE: There has been a reduction, as I mentioned, around the number of children in care and coming into care. Absolutely, to your point, it is about children aging out and reaching age of majority and moving on. It is also about the implementation of the shift that we’re making in the way that we practise and really trying our very best to support families in keeping children home and safe. That’s also contributed to the reduction in number of children in care.

 

When children are in care, we’ve really strengthened the supports to help them transition away from care, but even during their time in care. Unfortunately, children and youth may not always stay for a long time in a place. We are always looking to have a place for them to live that is in their best interests and always looking to their families or foster families first.

 

Transitional support looks like ongoing activity, connection, and planning through a child’s time in care with direct contact and engagement with their social worker. Transitions from care are also supported. We’ve updated our policies and procedures and are supporting youth to transition from care in their adolescence and early teen years, really focusing on sustainable connections and relationships, helping youth feel a sense of belonging where they are or where they want to be. Then the enhanced programs around the post-care support attachment to education and employment. Also, the Path program in terms of financial support and youth outreach is really helping to see a number of youth successfully transition to adulthood with support.

 

DIANNE TIMMINS: That was one of the questions as well: for pathways to look at the numbers and how successful that has been. Are there some improvements within the Path program that can have better outcomes for that youth?

 

JILL BARKHOUSE: Yes, the Path program - I think the end of August was providing support to 357 youth. That is a great number of young people who have been in care or who have received child and family well-being services through a youth service agreement who can be supported not only financially but through connection to a youth outreach support worker and support system with our service organization partners in communities across the province. They have regular check-ins. They have support to help them with life skills, with budgeting, with relationships, and navigating all the things into adulthood. The Path program has seen success.

 

There has recently been an evaluation of the Path program. We’re really looking to see what we’ve learned since it’s been implemented. We’re hearing what youth have told us about what impacts it has had for them and where we need to improve. Looking at ways to spread the word that youth who transition from care before Path but are in that age range can come back. We’re certainly looking at that and finding ways to engage more youth for that service and support.

 

DIANNE TIMMINS: The youth who are in care and who are participating in the Path program or education, do they stay within their family unit that they’re presently in or are there other housing arrangements that are implemented?

 

JILL BARKHOUSE: The Path program is really respecting that former youth are now adults, so trying to respect autonomy and decision-making and their own agency around what that plan looks like. They can live in a number of places, so some youth will return to family and community after a time in care. Other youth can be supported in independent living arrangements with apartments or situations where they’re living with others - friends, family. It depends, and the Path program is very specific to a youth’s needs. There isn’t a model that is applied as a standardized approach, but it is very much tailored to a specific youth’s needs and circumstances and what support might look like for them.

 

DIANNE TIMMINS: Okay, I’m going to move my questions on.

 

THE CHAIR: MLA Burns, please.

 

RICK BURNS: Thank you for coming in this morning. A lot of difficult conversation. In the interest of time as we get late into our meeting, I’m going to combine a couple of questions I have here. It may cross a couple of people, but I wanted to ask questions about the recommendations from the AG report. Specifically, Recommendation 1.5 calls for the department to “regularly monitor the agreements with temporary emergency service providers to assess whether services providers are complying with all terms and conditions.” Recommendation 1.6 calls for the department to “require staff to document the rationale behind the selection of a specific child and youth care home for a child.”

 

I wonder if you’d be able to address the steps that have been made on these recommendations, and where they’re at today.

 

THE CHAIR: Ms. Barkhouse.

 

JILL BARKHOUSE: Those recommendations have both been fully implemented. We’re happy to say that we have made progress in both of these areas.

 

In terms of the first one that was mentioned, in terms of oversight and compliance with TEAs, there is a multi-system approach to that oversight. I would say it would start with child-specific plans and contact. When social workers are responding to children and having contact with them, that contact is frequent and regular. It is done with a child one-on-one. It is done with the child in the place where they live to see their surroundings and make sure that is familiar and comfortable and to address any needs. A social worker absolutely has some ability to monitor how that arrangement is going for a specific child.

 

We also have some oversight in terms of system accountability with our TEA providers as partners. There is some random selection of reviews of staff who work with those organizations who provide temporary emergency arrangements. Those are for the purpose of confirming that the appropriate background checks are in place, that appropriate training needs are met, and to learn what else is needed in terms of supporting staff to provide their best care to children in those arrangements.

 

In terms of the second piece around documentation - the rationale for the selection of a specific home for a child - each time a child or youth in care needs a place to live, those decisions are initiated by the youth’s circumstances. Wherever possible, the youth has voice into what that plan is and where they want to be. The social worker does complete a tool or a form that helps inform decision-making, that considers the child’s strengths, their needs, their identity, factors around what their medical or other needs are. That information is used to help make a decision about where best they could live.

 

There is a process of care navigation. It is for every particular youth that decisions are made based on their particular needs and the most suitable arrangement that are available for them. That has some oversight provincially so that there’s a line of sight about each of these programs and which could best meet the needs, and which could be least disruptive for the children who already live there, perhaps. So there’s a lot of consideration when we’re making decisions about where children live. Those are documented to be explicit and transparent in the documentation about a child. That is their story of involvement with our program and the supports that they have, so we want to be very honest and upfront about how those decisions are made and what was considered.

 

THE CHAIR: MLA Burns with 15 seconds.

 

RICK BURNS: Thank you for the thorough answer and all the hard work that each of you in your department put into taking care of these children in the system every day. I want to thank you for coming out today. With that, I will wrap up.

 

THE CHAIR: That concludes our time for questions. Wondering if you have any closing remarks. Deputy Minister Beaton.

 

CRAIG BEATON: Just a thank you to the committee for the interest, obviously, in this one. I would just say that we’re here and get the opportunity to answer questions on behalf of the committee for the committee, but there are a number of people at the department who do help us prepare data and get information ready to give our best answers, so just a thank you to them. I appreciate the time here today.

 

[10:45 a.m.]

 

THE CHAIR: Thank you very much to all three of you for coming in and to all the staff in the department. Now you may go. We’re going to continue with a bunch of committee business. We’ll just take an unofficial one-minute break. Or maybe we have to take an official one-minute break. Just for one minute. Don’t use the bathroom. (Laughter)

 

[10:45 a.m. The committee recessed.]

 

[10:46 a.m. The committee reconvened.]

 

THE CHAIR: Order, please. We will bring the meeting back to order. We have a number of things on our agenda for committee business. The first is correspondence. The first piece of correspondence is the Department of Education and Early Childhood Development, which was information that was requested from the June 3rd meeting. You’ve all been given that correspondence. Any discussion on that?

 

Second is the Department of Health and Wellness - information requested from the April 29th meeting. Everyone was given that information. I’ll call on MLA Lachance.

 

LISA LACHANCE: I’m wondering about following up with the department on the answer to the first question, which is the left-without-being-seen data. We’re assured that it’s being collected internally but can’t be shared publicly, and there’s no update given in terms of when that information will be available publicly. I believe it’s an important metric, and I think it’s one that’s shared across provinces. I’m wondering what our ability is to write back to the department and say, essentially, “That answer isn’t good enough. When is it going to be publicly available for Nova Scotians?”

 

THE CHAIR: We can definitely do that. Any other discussion on that? Do we need a motion for that? Can’t hurt. MLA Lachance, would you make a motion on that?

 

LISA LACHANCE: Yes. I move that the Chair of PAC respond to the letter dated June 25th, 2026, from the Department of Health and Wellness and ask for an update on the left-without-being-seen data and indicate that it should be made public to Nova Scotians.

 

THE CHAIR: A motion is on the table. Is there any other discussion on the motion? MLA Boudreau.

 

HON. TREVOR BOUDREAU: I just want to look at the second paragraph of that response, which is: “We expect this reporting to improve as documentation and information flows are strengthened,” which includes using when the OPOR is implemented. So they’re kind of saying, “We are going to get to this information. When OPOR is fully operational and we have that data stabilization, we’ll be able to provide that.” That’s what my interpretation of it was. I understand, but I think they’re trying to say, “When we get OPOR up and running, and when we have that period of data stabilization, we’ll be able to get you that info.” So for those reasons, I’m not in support of this motion.

 

THE CHAIR: I just want to contemplate. Both arguments are good, but what if the information is available but we never get a follow-up? That is part of our work, is to make sure we’re getting follow-ups. I’ll just go to MLA Lachance first.

 

LISA LACHANCE: I appreciate that, and I appreciate the notes, but that’s a fairly wide-open response in terms of there’s absolutely no target date given. There’s no definition of what data stabilization means. I just feel like the first sentence says that it’s being documented and it’s monitored internally. So my question is: If it’s being documented and monitored internally, even if how that data might look might change with OPOR and that sort of thing. Nova Scotians need access to this. We have an emergency health system that’s in crisis. Nova Scotians know this. They know what it’s like trying to seek emergency care, and this is an important metric. This really should be something that is available to the public.

 

TREVOR BOUDREAU: I appreciate the thought process to that, but I think we’ve heard today in terms of implementation, and sometimes it takes time to get data. My understanding is basically what they’re saying is that everybody’s collecting the same data, the same way through OPOR and we’re able to document it that way, then we’ll be able to have that information and it will take some time to gather once OPOR is created so that we can provide that information. I don’t see them saying we can’t do this. I think that’s my point.

 

Again, I appreciate it. I think at some point if we want to raise a point saying, “OPOR has been implemented, you’ve had a year to collect that data, we haven’t seen this metric,” we can bring it back it back up. I think at this point we have something that says we will do it when we have that information. I appreciate the comments.

 

THE CHAIR: MLA Taggart.

 

TOM TAGGART: My question is: When we talk about people who left the OR without being seen - I’m sorry, the ER without being seen (Interruptions) When they leave the emergency room without being seen, that doesn’t mean they haven’t been triaged, is that right? They’ve been triaged, but they just haven’t seen a doctor. Is that correct?

 

THE CHAIR: This is beyond my pay level. MLA Druhan.

 

BECKY DRUHAN: I would suggest that that would be helpful information that could be included in the response from the Department of Health and Wellness.

 

TOM TAGGART: No, that does not satisfy me. Like most others here, I’ve been in emergency rooms or emergency departments. You’re technically triaged within 5 or 10 minutes. Then you go and somebody prioritizes that wait-list. think there are just too many variables to even try to answer that question. I’m not going to support it.

 

THE CHAIR: Okay, I’m going to go to MLA Lachance one more time and then I’m going to call the question, please. MLA Lachance.

 

LISA LACHANCE: I guess the point is if we want to understand this data better, we should ask for it. It is a metric that is maintained across provinces - the left without being seen. In that way, it’s an important metric. IWK Health and the Central Zone have now implemented One Person One Record. I’d be happy to amend the request that we be provided with that data.

 

THE CHAIR: Sorry, what data are you…

 

LISA LACHANCE: That we would ask the Department of Health and Wellness to follow up with the data for left without being seen or at least a date for when we could expect it for IWK Health and the Central Zone now that they have the system in place.

 

THE CHAIR: How do we handle that one, Madam Legal Counsel? That’s an amendment on one’s own motion. Is that a possibility? A friendly amendment? (Interruption) It’s a what? (Interruption) Okay, MLA Lachance.

 

LISA LACHANCE: Based on the discussion we’ve had here at the table, I’d like to withdraw my original motion.

 

THE CHAIR: Okay, and I need to call a vote on that.

 

There’s a motion to withdraw the motion.

 

All those in favour? Contrary minded? Thank you.

 

The motion is carried.

 

MLA Lachance.

 

LISA LACHANCE: I would like to move that the committee respond to the Department of Health and Wellness based on this response and ask for the left-without-being-seen information that’s currently documented in settings where OPOR has been fully implemented, such as IWK Health and the Central Zone, be shared with the committee.

 

THE CHAIR: There is a motion on the table. Any discussion on that motion?

 

All those in favour? Contrary minded? Thank you.

 

The motion is defeated.

 

I’m going to move on. Thank you very much for that discussion, folks. We’re running out of time. Could I ask for a motion to extend for five minutes? MLA Outhit.

 

All those in favour? Contrary minded? Thank you.

 

The motion is carried.

 

The next item for correspondence is the Department of Service Nova Scotia - Information requested from the June 10th meeting. Any discussion on that? MLA Lachance.

 

LISA LACHANCE: Listen, this is what happens when you break a bone and you sit still longer to get through all the correspondence twice. (Laughter) The question had been about the health and social services exemption for alternative procurement and how many times it had been used. They provided that information. It totals a fairly astronomical amount. I’m wondering how we as the committee can ask for further updates on this. Because it’s being considered at the committee, is it possible to say, “Thank you for this, can you let us know next year what happens?” I’m wondering what the function could be.

 

THE CHAIR: I think that we can simply do that. We can set a date and have another follow-up letter ready for a year from the original request, thanking them for the information and asking for an update. (Interruption) I guess we’d need a motion for that and then agreement to do that. MLA Boudreau.

 

TREVOR BOUDREAU: Are we basically saying we want the same information that we just received next year?

 

THE CHAIR: Yes. Based on our discussions at our conference, it’s a good way to make sure that as a committee we’re holding departments to account and making sure that the AG reports are top of mind for folks. This is a very usual and appropriate role for the committee, these kinds of letters. MLA Lachance, can I have a motion?

 

LISA LACHANCE: Yes. I move that the committee write the Department of Service Nova Scotia and ask for this information on how many times these exemptions have been used under alternative procurement, ask for this to be provided on an annual basis. Thus, the next update would be June 24, 2027.

 

THE CHAIR: The motion is on the table. Any discussion?

 

All those in favour? Contrary minded? Thank you.

 

The motion is carried.

 

The next piece of correspondence is the Department of Growth and Development - information requested from the June 17th meeting. Any discussion on that piece of correspondence? Great.

 

The Department of Energy - information requested from the May 13th meeting. Any discussion on that? Seeing none, we’ll move on.

 

The Department of Finance and Treasury Board - information requested from the June 10th meeting. Any discussion?

 

Then the Office of the Auditor General, correspondence dated June 30, 2026, regarding the 2025-26 Performance Report, the 2026-27 Business Plan, and the 2025-26 Audited Financial Statements. Any discussion on those pieces of correspondence?

 

Finally for correspondence, we have emails from Debra Lalonde dated June 27, 2026, and July 15, 2026. Any discussion on those emails?

 

The next piece on the agenda is the Subcommittee on Agenda and Procedures Record Of Decision. The subcommittee met on September 23rd to review witnesses for a number of Auditor General reports. Members have been provided with a copy of the record of decision. I need to ask you for a motion to approve the record of decision. Could I have a motion to approve? MLA Outhit.

 

TIM OUTHIT: I’ll move that.

 

THE CHAIR: Just to be clear, you’re moving the record of decision of September 23, 2026.

 

All those in favour? Contrary minded? Thank you.

 

The motion is carried.

 

The next thing on the agenda is Nova Scotia’s Community Housing Sector - Witnesses. The approved witnesses for this topic are: the Deputy Minister of Growth and Development; the Chair of the Nova Scotia Non-Profit Housing Association; the Director of Development, Community Housing Transformation Centre; Affordable Housing Association of Nova Scotia. The Director of Development for the Community Housing Transformation Centre has retired; Executive Director Lisa Ker has indicated she will attend on behalf of the Centre.

 

[11:00 a.m.]

 

Is the committee in agreement with the executive director, Lisa Ker, appearing on behalf of the Community Housing Transformation Centre? No problems? (Interruption) Do we need a motion?

 

Everyone agrees with that? Okay, perfect. Thank you.

 

Also, Michael Kabalen is the executive director of AHANS and the chair of the Nova Scotia Non-Profit Housing Association as well. He has indicated that he’s able to attend but will need approval to appear in both capacities - or whether another board member will appear in his capacity as chair of the Nova Scotia Non-Profit Housing Association or as the executive director. We wanted to make sure that the committee was aware of this, that Michael could be wearing two hats, or should they send another board member from AHANS?

 

MLA Taggart.

 

TOM TAGGART: I think this guy’s capable. I often think we have too many witnesses. People don’t get questions. We have four witnesses? Five? Yes, we’re good.

 

THE CHAIR: The issue is Mr. Kabalen is going to his boards of both associations to make sure he can wear both hats at the meeting. If the boards say, “No, we’d rather send someone else,” then we will have one more person because the topic was approved with the organizations, not the people. I’m just saying that in this case, if the boards do not agree, MLA Taggart, then, in fact, we would have an extra person at the meeting, not fewer. (Interruption) The same number of people.

 

KIM LANGILLE: Just the one person would be representing both or not. (Laughs)

 

THE CHAIR: I think it’s fine. (Interruption) Yes, okay. (Interruption) It’s not up to us, ultimately, right? (Interruption) Okay.

 

Well, that’s it for committee business. Our next meeting date will be October 14, 2026. That’s an in-camera meeting. It is with the Canadian Audit and Accountability Foundation and it’s training. A reminder that the meeting is from 9:00 a.m. until 1:00 p.m., folks, 9:00 a.m. until 1:00 p.m. with lunch provided. Did everyone hear me say 9:00 a.m. until 1:00 p.m.? Lunch provided.

 

If there’s no further business, I will adjourn the meeting. Thank you very much.

 

[The committee adjourned at 11:03 a.m.]